In 1990, Harvard Business School professor Michael E. Porter
argued that
"The Competitive Advantage of Nations"
was the capacity of their industries to innovate and
upgrade. Now the bankruptcy code of the United States
may be a new competitive advantage for American companies.
In a recent
USA Today
article
, Dennis Cauchon reports on how companies use bankruptcies
to shed themselves of pension obligations, union contracts and
other onerous burdens. He quotes University of Michigan law
professor John Pottow, who declares that, "Chapter 11 in the
United States is the darling of the international business
world. If you are a company or even a rich person, you can
go into the bankruptcy system and confront your failures, and you
will not be punished."
In contrast, English law demands that management be fired when
a company declares bankruptcy. Other countries liquidate bankrupt
firms or require years of debt payments.
Due to the differences in treatment, many companies utilize
the bankruptcy code as a form of business planning. Every
legacy air carrier in the United States has now filed for
bankruptcy -- American Airlines (
AMR
,
quote
) being just the most recent -- using the restructuring to
develop a more viable business model.
Having a more lenient bankruptcy code allows companies to be
more daring. That is the spirit of entrepreneurism.
While there is much to be said for a company meeting all
its obligations, keeping operations going in bad times rewards
everyone involved. Employees still have a job, customers
can remain loyal and creditors can work out compensation
arrangements. A straight liquidation benefits no one if a
working agreement can be secured.